|
Mutual
Funds: Gain Without Pain
This article was
published in March 2006 by Risk-Controlled Investing, Charter
Financial Publishing Network, Charter
Financial Publishing Network, Shrewsbury, NJ 07702.
732-450-8866.
Mutual fund
shareholders sometimes find themselves owing capital gains taxes
on their funds in years when they have not redeemed any shares or
taken any income out of their fund.
Sometimes they may owe capital gains taxes on funds that
have actually lost value. The
reason is that mutual fund realized capital gains flow through to
participants near the end of each year.
But investors may diminish the effect of this problem if
they choose funds with embedded capital losses.
Capital losses do not flow through to investors but can be
used to shelter future capital gains taken by the fund.
For
this reason, in the past, Twenty-First Securities has suggested
that mutual fund investors consider funds with capital loss
carryforwards. An
investor should not buy into a fund just because it has loss
carryforwards, but if a fund has an investment style that you’re
looking for, then large loss carryforwards may make it even more
attractive.
One
possible problem with this approach is that open-end funds can
always dilute their losses by issuing more shares to new
investors. For
example, suppose a fund has 10 million shares outstanding and
total capital losses of $100 million; that fund’s loss per share
is $10. But if that fund issues another 10 million shares, the
capital loss per share falls to only $5.
Investors
can avoid this dilution effect by looking for embedded capital
losses in closed-end funds. A
closed-end fund, by definition, cannot issue new shares.
So the loss carryforward, in effect, is safe from dilution.
Research by Herzfeld Advisors shows that a number of closed-end
funds have substantial embedded losses - especially high
income/high yield funds and funds investing in Asia. For
example, the Thai Capital Fund has a loss carryforward that is
bigger than the total assets in the fund. With Dreyfus High
Yield Strategies Fund, the price is $3.95 per share while the loss
carryforward is $9.01 per share. So these funds can afford
many good years before the fund would need to pay capital gain
distributions.
A
list of closed-end funds that, as of November 2005, have a large proportion of capital
losses per share is set forth below:
| Type |
Symbol |
Name |
NAV |
Loss Carry-
forward |
Loss As % Of
Assets |
| Specialized
Equity |
FXX |
Foxby Corp. |
2.42 |
6.37 |
263% |
| Bond |
DHF |
Dreyfus High
Yield Strategies Fund |
4.51 |
9.01 |
200% |
| Bond |
HIS |
CIGNA High
Income Shares |
2.61 |
4.67 |
179% |
| Bond |
PHY |
Prospect
Street High Income Portfolio |
3.20 |
5.56 |
174% |
| Foreign
Equity |
TF |
Thai Capital
Fund |
8.91 |
14.85 |
167% |
| Foreign
Equity |
MF |
Malaysia Fund |
5.76 |
7.32 |
127% |
| Bond |
HYF |
Managed High
Yield Plus Fund |
4.74 |
5.72 |
121% |
| Bond |
HYP |
High Yield
Plus Fund |
3.73 |
4.28 |
115% |
| Bond |
DHY |
Credit Suisse
High Yield Bond Fund |
4.13 |
4.5 |
109% |
| Bond |
AMF |
ACM Managed
Income Fund |
3.94 |
4.18 |
106% |
| Foreign
Equity |
TTF |
Thai Fund |
8.23 |
8.57 |
104% |
| Foreign
Equity |
GRR |
Asia Tigers
Fund |
13.87 |
14 |
101% |
| Bond |
ZIF |
Zenix Income
Fund |
2.95 |
2.93 |
99% |
| Foreign
Equity |
TFC |
Taiwan
Greater China Fund |
5.15 |
5.05 |
98% |
| Bond |
MSY |
Morgan
Stanley High Yield Fund |
6.57 |
6.19 |
94% |
| Bond |
HYB |
New America
High Income Fund |
2.15 |
1.89 |
88% |
| Bond |
CIF |
Colonial
Intermediate High Income Fund |
3.60 |
3.01 |
84% |
| Foreign
Equity |
ETF |
Emerging
Markets Telecommunications Fund |
13.01 |
10.22 |
79% |
| Bond |
VLT |
Van Kampen
High Income Trust II |
4.26 |
3.28 |
77% |
| Foreign
Bond |
MGB |
Morgan
Stanley Global Opportunity Bond Fund |
7.99 |
6.07 |
76% |
| Bond |
CIK |
Credit Suisse
Income Fund |
4.20 |
3.15 |
75% |
| Bond |
CIM |
CIM High
Yield Securities |
4.25 |
3.17 |
75% |
| Bond |
BHY |
BlackRock
High Yield Trust |
7.47 |
5.53 |
74% |
| Bond |
CYE |
Corporate
High Yield Fund III |
8.42 |
6.16 |
73% |
| Bond |
ADF |
ACM Managed
Dollar Income Fund |
8.04 |
5.82 |
72% |
| Bond |
HIO |
High Income
Opportunity Fund |
7.05 |
4.41 |
63% |
| Bond |
MHY |
Managed High
Income Portfolio |
6.84 |
4.23 |
62% |
| Foreign
Equity |
GF |
New Germany
Fund |
11.17 |
6.81 |
61% |
| Foreign
Equity |
KEF |
Korea Equity
Fund |
8.70 |
5.3 |
61% |
| Foreign
Bond |
LBF |
Scudder
Global High Income Fund |
8.92 |
5.43 |
61% |
| Foreign
Equity |
IF |
Indonesia
Fund |
5.34 |
3.22 |
60% |
| Foreign
Equity |
JFC |
Jardine
Fleming China Region Fund |
14.85 |
8.25 |
56% |
| Bond |
COY |
Corporate
High Yield Fund |
8.49 |
4.57 |
54% |
| Bond |
CNN |
Prospect
Street Income Shares |
6.21 |
3.32 |
53% |
| Foreign
Equity |
ZSEV |
Z-Seven Fund |
5.77 |
2.93 |
51% |
| Bond |
PTM |
Putnam
Managed HighYield Trust |
9.00 |
4.44 |
49% |
| Bond |
DSU |
Debt
Strategies Fund |
6.43 |
3.09 |
48% |
| Bond |
KHI |
Scudder High
Income Trust |
5.87 |
2.72 |
46% |
| Bond |
ARK |
Senior High
Income Portfolio |
5.83 |
2.7 |
46% |
| Specialized
Equity |
CWF |
Chartwell
Dividend and Income Fund |
8.57 |
3.94 |
46% |
| Specialized
Equity |
ZF |
Zweig Fund |
5.62 |
2.38 |
42% |
| Bond |
PHF |
Pacholder
HighYield Fund |
8.88 |
3.72 |
42% |
| Specialized
Equity |
MVC |
MVC Capital |
10.41 |
3.99 |
38% |
| Bond |
HYI |
High Yield
Income Fund |
5.44 |
2.05 |
38% |
| Convertible |
CVT |
TCW
Convertible Securities Fund |
5.41 |
2.01 |
37% |
| Foreign
Equity |
JEQ |
Japan Equity
Fund |
7.86 |
2.9 |
37% |
| Bond |
CFD |
40/86
Strategic Income Fund |
10.71 |
3.91 |
37% |
| Specialized
Equity |
AMO |
Alliance
All-Market Advantage Fund |
14.41 |
5.09 |
35% |
| Bond |
FT |
Franklin
Universal Trust |
6.85 |
2.37 |
35% |
| Foreign
Equity |
SGF |
Singapore
Fund |
10.69 |
3.59 |
34% |
| Foreign
Equity |
TWN |
Taiwan Fund |
14.39 |
4.36 |
30% |
| Foreign
Equity |
APF |
Morgan
Stanley Asia Pacific Fund |
15.96 |
4.71 |
30% |
| Bond |
PPT |
Putnam
Premier Income Trust |
7.03 |
2.05 |
29% |
| Equity |
CRF |
Cornerstone
Total Return Fund |
11.02 |
3.09 |
28% |
| Municipal
Bond |
CMU |
Colonial
Municipal Income Trust |
5.73 |
1.55 |
27% |
| Loan
Participation |
PPR |
ING Prime
Rate Trust |
7.41 |
1.98 |
27% |
| Foreign
Bond |
MSD |
Morgan
Stanley Emerging Market Debt Fund |
10.84 |
2.85 |
26% |
| Municipal
Bond |
CXE |
Colonial High
Income Municipal Trust |
6.44 |
1.61 |
25% |
| Bond |
HSF |
Hartford
Income Shares Fund |
7.82 |
1.9 |
24% |
| Specialized
Equity |
EQS |
Equus II |
11.40 |
2.46 |
22% |
| Equity |
TY |
Tri-Continental
Corp. |
21.73 |
4.67 |
21% |
| Bond |
HIF |
Salomon
Brothers High Income Fund |
10.43 |
2.17 |
21% |
| Bond |
HIX |
Salomon
Brothers High Income Fund II |
11.47 |
2.35 |
20% |
| Bond |
ACG |
ACM Income
Fund |
8.11 |
1.66 |
20% |
| Bond |
BKT |
BlackRock
Income Trust |
6.53 |
1.27 |
19% |
| Bond |
PIM |
Putnam Master
Intermediate Income Trust |
6.98 |
1.34 |
19% |
| Municipal
Bond |
PYM |
Putnam High
Yield Municipal Trust |
7.76 |
1.48 |
19% |
| Municipal
Bond |
AMU |
ACM Municipal
Securities Income Fund |
11.08 |
2.11 |
19% |
Sources:
NAV : Bloomberg. http://www.bloomberg.com,
November 10, 2005.
Loss Carrryforwards: Thomas J. Herzfeld Advisors, “Survey of
Closed-End Fund Loss Carryforwards,” The Investor’s Guide
to Closed-End Funds, November 2005.
Used with permission.
Investments in
mutual funds involve risk, including, without limitation,
the risk that these funds may employ leverage and other
speculative investment practices, and that an investor can
lose all or a substantial part of his investment.
Before
buying a mutual fund, investors should carefully consider
the fund’s investment objectives, risks, and charges and
expenses. Fund prospectuses contain this and other
information. Investors may obtain prospectuses at http://www.sec.gov/edgar.shtml.
They should read prospectuses carefully before investing.
|
This
article and other articles are provided for
information purposes only. They are not intended to be
an offer to engage in any securities transactions or to
provide specific financial, legal or tax advice. Articles
may have been rendered partly inaccurate by events that have
occurred since publication. Investors should consult
their advisers before acting on any topics discussed herein.
Options involve risk and are not suitable for all
investors. Before engaging in an options
transaction, investors must review the booklet "Characteristics
and Risks of Standardized Options".
|
|